By Erica Riray
In Congresswoman Karen Bass’s speech for LMU’s Constitution Day, she reminded us that college students are not immune to COVID-19. Yet as students return to Los Angeles, many appear to be unfazed by the risks of the current pandemic when throwing parties and large gatherings.
At the time this article was written, LA Public Health reported 279,909 COVID-19 cases in LA County, a number that is increasing by about 1,250 a day. Fatality rates have slowed, but 6,741 people have died from COVID-19 in LA County to date.
Some LMU students who weren’t able to secure on-campus housing still find themselves living close to campus, occupying buildings in Playa Vista and Westchester. In attempts to replicate what is left of the college experience away from the Bluff, groups of friends are quarantining together, attending Zoom lectures in the same rooms and leaning on each other for emotional support that they may not receive back home.
But COVID outbreaks in colleges across the country tell us that the pandemic poses a threat to the fun. Despite strict precautions that mirror those released by LMU in early August, the University of Southern California (USC) experienced a spike in cases, according to USC Chief Student Health Officer Sarah Van Orman. Students have been found throwing parties in off-campus apartments, in one instance causing a COVID-19 outbreak that put over a hundred people in quarantine.
Similarly, California State University, Long Beach (CSULB) reported an outbreak of COVID-19 cases directly related to large gatherings of students on and off campus near the end of September. This outbreak put approximately 328 on-campus residents in quarantine and CSULB has since asked off-campus community members to self-isolate.
USC and CSULB’s neighborhoods are home to Black and Brown communities who are particularly vulnerable to the coronavirus. The Center for Disease Control (CDC) has reported that racial and ethnic minority groups are more likely to contract COVID-19 due to social inequities including access to healthcare, occupation and housing. In addition to facing gentrification and increasing rent, a deadly virus is now brewing in their backyards.
LMU students are capable of quickly catching and spreading COVID-19 to the most vulnerable members of the community in the same way. Black and Brown residents have occupied the neighborhoods surrounding LMU for years. In Westchester, the minority groups listed in the CDC’s report make up 48% of the population. About four miles away in Inglewood, they make up about 70%.
In an October 2020 report, the CDC has concluded that young adults significantly contribute to community transmission of COVID-19. The CDC’s new data confirms that people ages 20-29 make up the highest percentage of COVID-19 cases nationwide, surpassing adults aged 60 and older.
To accommodate public health guidelines, the university has reduced housing occupancy to one student per unit with Resident Directors enforcing housing rules.
Sophomore Cobe Alvarez is currently living alone in an on-campus apartment. His experience has been comfortable and safe since Resident Directors are actively limiting entrance into buildings.
Alvarez expressed that seeing other residents’ social media posts of small kickbacks and gatherings worry him due to how the virus could be spread through these activities.
“I would say I'm more concerned about students doing stuff off campus, [or] students living on campus and going off campus, than I am about [living] on campus specifically,” said Alvarez.
LMU has also promoted safety on and off campus during the pandemic. Over the Labor Day weekend, LMU released a “Protect the Pride” video on social media. Students from Sorority and Fraternity Life (SFL) encouraged students to follow social distancing guidelines. LMU has also been updating their “LMU Together” page and adopting the motto “EIBC,” short for Excellent Infectious Behavior Control.
“[EIBC] encourages students to monitor their behavior, stand six feet apart, wear their masks [and] not gather in large groups of three or more,” explained Amiya Powell-Hodge, interim Assistant Director of Off-Campus Student Life.
Playa Del Oro (PDO), an apartment building minutes from campus, is primarily occupied by LMU students every year given its proximity to campus, and this semester is no different. Sophomore PDO resident Meghan Quadracci reported that the building has been promoting distancing and limiting entrance to shared spaces like the pool. But unlike the residents living on campus, there are no Resident Directors or Public Safety officers to enforce distancing and the number of guests in the apartments.
In an email sent out to LMU’s Service Organization Community (SOC) in September, Center for Service and Action (CSA) Assistant Director for Student Engagement Chelsea Brown reprimanded large gatherings that were allegedly reported and pleaded with students to stop.
“[W]e are only on day 2 of the semester and there have already been reports of students gathering in large groups at houses outside the back gates and in Playa Del Oro,” Brown wrote. “Here’s the thing: please don’t.”
It is unclear if the university has taken any action regarding these specific reports or exactly whom these incidents of gatherings were reported to.
Off-campus residents who hold gatherings may also face consequences from the local government. The LA County Health Officer Order’s Impact on Daily Life explicitly states that “individual and family gatherings or parties of any size aren’t allowed.” LA Mayor Eric Garcetti has also threatened to shut off utilities for those who violate public health orders such as these.
Powell-Hodge explained that LMU has taken a more restorative approach over a punitive one to violations of COVID-19 preventative procedures.
“We are addressing it with care and compassion as we would anything else,” said Powell-Hodge.
If a neighboring member of the community files a complaint, the university writes a report and Off Campus Student Life will follow up with students as needed. There have been no complaints publicly reported by LMU.
University life has changed drastically with the pandemic. LMU has made resources available to students but is not directly policing them. Students are the only ones responsible for their individual decisions.
Powell-Hodge wants to remind students to “consider your values and who you value. This is a time for us to be creative about the way we conceptualize community and we have to do that with every member of our community in mind. That is what’s going to help us return to our campus life.”
Unclean labor: PPE, Prisoners and the Pandemic
By Andrea Guardiola
The United States was unprepared for the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, despite the fact that we had plenty of warning. Instead of buying supplies from ethical providers or other countries, many states have turned to prison labor to deal with shortages and soaring prices for basic Personal Protective Equipment (PPE). Prisoners have been producing masks, gowns, hand sanitizer, and more for remarkably low wages.
Prison labor is exploitative all on its own outside of a pandemic. However, given that the conditions of prison are highly conducive to incarcerated people catching and spreading COVID-19, this practice is made even crueler and more dangerous. Considering prisoners are not sufficiently protected from the virus, having these workers risk their lives for pennies to manufacture protection for other people adds insult to injury.
New York employed incarcerated people at Rikers Island to dig mass graves for COVID-19 victims for six dollars an hour. Many of these people were being detained pre-trial, meaning a large number of unconvicted people were being exploited by the state to supply essential services. In Texas, inmates earn no wages for making protective equipment such as masks and gowns for first responders.
The California Prison Industry Authority (CALPIA) is a business responsible for contracting the labor of incarcerated people in California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) facilities. CALPIA contracts incarcerated labor in CDCR facilities to make hand sanitizer and masks. CALPIA generates a profit of approximately 80 cents per mask from this practice by “selling hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of masks and sanitizer to state government agencies.”
Corporations in the business of contracting prison labor can only remain operational at the expense of incarcerated people, and CALPIA is no exception. While CDCR staff and incarcerated people are allowed to use the sanitizer, this does not justify underpaying prisoners and making a profit at their expense.
Paying people inadequate wages to do something essential is exploitive. This is true not only because workers deserve to be compensated for their labor but also because prisoners are already economically vulnerable. Cheating them out of fair wages exacerbates that vulnerability. Prisoners use marginal wages earned from prison labor not only for necessities while incarcerated (phone calls, tampons and other hygiene products, for example) but also for legal fines and general cost of living post release. Incarcerated people working in the CALPIA system get 40% of their already meager wages—35 cent to one dollar per hour—taken out of their paycheck for court ordered restitution and fees.
The general manager of CALPIA, Scott Walker, boasted that “[f]rom start to finish, this process took two weeks to deliver, which is remarkable considering it could take many months.” The efficiency of mask and sanitizer production Walker brags about means prisoners were probably overworked and underpaid. They can’t unionize for better pay or working conditions, and have no other means of securing these benefits. .
CALPIA claims that all work is optional for prisoners. However, incarcerated people often have too many financial obligations in and out of prison to give up any kind of work or pay.
“With no savings, how can people possibly afford the immediate costs of food, housing, healthcare, transportation, child support, and supervision fees once released?” reads the Prison Policy Initiative.
The risk of contracting COVID-19 in prison remains high while incarcerated people make the supplies to help people outside prisons stay safe from the virus. Non-violent and low-risk inmates were set to be released to slow the spread of COVID-19 in prisons, however, many were never released, meaning that correctional facilities remained overcrowded.
When the pandemic started, hand sanitizer prices surged. New York governor Andrew Cuomo “solved” the issue by having prisoners make sanitizer for 65 cents an hour. However, due to the high alcohol content of the hand sanitizer, it is unclear whether these sanitizers will qualify as contraband in New York.
California State Prison in Los Angeles is also underpaying incarcerated people to make hand sanitizer. As of early May, 90 inmates at the facility producing sanitizer in LA have tested positive for COVID-19. This is beyond exploitative. Ignoring the danger faced by incarcerated people in prisons while having them make protection for others is risking and devaluing their lives.
These exploitative practices are exacerbated by the sins of the prison industrial complex. The fact that the prisons in the US are disproportionately composed of Black people means this practice is yet another instance in United States history in which Black people are expected to literally build this country for almost nothing in return. Even though most of the PPE being produced by prisoners is for first responders, and even for prison staff and inmates, profiting off of these prisoners is corrupt, especially during a pandemic.
[EDITOR’S NOTE: If you are looking for ethically sourced PPE, there are several Black-owned businesses making and selling masks on Etsy.]
Social Icons